I enjoy in person poetry readings but I prefer reading a poem, savoring it, without any external embellishments the first time around. After I have read it I like to hear a poet read his or her work. I find that a person's voice often influences my reaction to a poem. I am influenced by sound, perhaps even prejudiced by it one way or the other. I want to get over my sound preferences when I hear a poet read a poem and my first reaction is no don't like it or wow fantastic. Hearing a poem and listening to a poem are two different things in my opinion. If you'd like to share your view, please post a comment.
A link about attitudes toward poetry readings.
The Peril of the Poetry Reading: The Page Versus the Performance- Poets.org
http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/5913